On Land

Environment Information
At Rill & Decker Architects we run ArchiCAD on Mac OS X. If you work at Rill & Decker, this is your stuff. If you don't, but you work in ArchiCAD, you may find something interesting. Anybody else, I don't know.
RSS

In the ArchiCAD library, there are niche objects, such as W Niche and W Niche Round. These are actually windows. They are built on the WALLNICHE GDL statement. The trouble with these niches is that with the Doors & Windows display option set to Hide on Plan or Reflected Ceiling, they appear to be full, through-wall openings. In addition, they may not handle composite walls correctly.

This is fine:



But when you turn the Doors & Windows off, you get a misleading graphic:



Instead, try a slab and an SEO subtraction.

For this method to work, you need a layer which shows in plan, but is hidden in section/elevation. I have a layer called ‘X SEO Show2’ for this purpose. The model setting of the layer should generally be wireframe. Use a cover fill on the slab to mask the wall. You might have to bring the slab forward a bit.



In 3D:



The slab method has these advantages:

• Display is independent of D & W Display Option.

• The niche can be hidden completely in non-architectural (e.g., framing) plans.

• The niche can have a different pen from the wall, if you ‘inherit attributes of operator’.

It's not perfect, though: The niche will not move if the wall is moved; a window would. Grouping the slab and the wall mitigates this somewhat.